Thoughts on LSU Letting Brian Kelly Go

RD and I just did a recent podcast in which we talked about coaches being let go during the season and the gambling epidemic in pro and college sports that is already making major headlines. During that episode I didn't fully agree with RD's take on in season coaching changes. In some cases I fully believe that a university should let a coach finish the season before getting rid of them. Doing it during the season halts every single thing that a college program can do to help itself. It slows recruiting, the product on the field gets worse and in the transfer portal era, it makes it so easy for a superstar player to seek greener pastures.

Now, you may notice I keep referring to universities, and that is fully on purpose. Professional sports is a totally different world with more than double the amount of money going into college programs. If an owner and their board want to relieve a head coach during the season in the pros, that is their prerogative. That's their money and they can do with it as they please. College coaches and pro coaches are a totally different breed.

Where I differed with RD when it involves college coaches being let go, I think if the product on and the off the field has gotten so bad, possibly even regressed, then an immediate change is needed. When Michigan fired Brady Hoke in the middle of his fourth season it felt justified and necessary. They had regressed every season under him, recruiting was mediocre and they had become a bad football program. He also allowed a concussed player to continue playing in a game. That was the final straw for me. I fully agree with UAB letting Trent Dilfer go a few weeks ago. He was not doing his job. There were videos and pictures of him taking pictures when UAB visited Tennessee earlier this year. You could tell he had zero faith in his team that afternoon and he just wanted some pictures to keep on his phone of the time his team got their teeth kicked in. Whenever there is some kind of scandal at a college involving a head coach, they have got to go too. There's no reason to keep someone around who is going to bring sanctions and violations in the very near future. We also have James Franklin from this season. I was not too stunned when Penn State let him go a few weeks back. He had done some quality things in his 11 years there, but he could never get over the hump. He had pretty much every advantage a head coach in the Big 10 could want in his time there but he never won anything major. He couldn't get it done and I'm sure some people at the university were ready for a change now. They didn't want to wait until the end of the season.

All of this brings me to the news of LSU relieving Brian Kelly of his duties yesterday. Again, on first blush I was a little shocked, but after reading some things and hearing some people talk, LSU has not done the things they have expected since luring Kelly away from Notre Dame. The three head coaches ahead of Kelly at LSU all won a SEC title and a national title. Sure, Nick Saban left for the pros, Les Miles turned out to be a creep and Ed Orgeron may have been giving payments before it was legal, but they all won. Saban built a powerful defense, Miles continued that and added a powerful run game and Orgeron knew how to use the portal before it was popular. And they all walked away from that school with a ring. Kelly never really did much in his three plus seasons. He had a 34-14 record in his time there, but he was never in the playoff, never won a SEC title, was never really in contention to be honest and he continually made an ass of himself to the media and fans. I'll never forget his speech he gave the LSU basketball crowd where he did a fake southern accent. He's from Maine and, prior to coaching LSU, he only coached in the midwest. That accent thing was nuts. Then he started to dance in recruiting videos. He's far too old for that. Then he wasn't able to secure his top commitment in last year's recruiting class, Bryce Underwood. And when Underwood signed with Michigan, Kelly complained about the lack of NIL. at LSU. That is wild.

And then we have the on field product this season. The offense has been inept. It reminds me of how Michigan's offense looked last year, but Garrett Nussmeier is a much better QB than Davis Warren, no disrespect to Warren. They have athletes on that side of the ball, but they haven't been able to put it together. And when they have played similar talent rich programs this season, they have been getting whooped. It all came to a head this past Saturday when Texas A&M beat them up pretty bad in Baton Rouge. The final score of that game was rough for LSU. They gave up over 40 points at home. I get that A&M is really, really good this season, but still, LSU got demolished. And they looked really bad while getting blown out.

All of this is to say that I understand why LSU made this decision this weekend. That school is supposed to be a blueblood. They should be in the playoff hunt every year, especially now with it being expanded. And that has not happened under his watch. I am curious to see who they target, but it will be a desirable job because it has pretty much always been a premier football program. i'm interested in their hiring process going forward. 

Ty

Ty is the Pop Culture editor for SeedSing and the other host of the X Millennial Man Podcast.

Come and support Ty and the podcast on Patreon.

Follow Ty on instagram.

SeedSing is funded by a group of awesome people. Join them by donating to SeedSing.